Garlic Knots
Fresh-pulled knots in garlic & oil with marinara to dip.
Authentic Italian Cuisine · Maybrook, NY
Hand-Tossed
NY-Style Pizza
Hand-tossed NY-style pizza, hot heroes, baked pasta & catering — made fresh for Maybrook. Slices, hot heroes, baked pasta, and catering for any crowd — right here on Homestead Ave.
Straight Out of the Oven
Famous For
Jumbo Wings
A dozen jumbo wings — hot, mild, honey BBQ, garlic parm or teriyaki.
Chicken Parm Hero
Breaded cutlet, marinara & mozzarella on a fresh hero roll.
Stromboli
Ham, salami & pepperoni rolled and baked golden.
Specialty Pies
BBQ, buffalo, chicken bacon ranch & more — piled edge to edge.
Cannoli
Crisp shell, sweet cream filling — save room for one.
Deals
Weekly Specials & Combo Deals
$12 large pizza every Monday & Tuesday, a free topping on Fridays, and a free 2-liter on Saturdays — plus weekday lunch specials and combo deals on pizza and wings.
See All Specials155 Reasons to Be Hungry
The Full Menu
Traditional & specialty pizza, hot & cold heroes, wraps, burgers, baked pasta dinners, salads, and full catering trays.
- Pizza
- Specialty Pizzas
- Appetizers & Sides
- Soups
- Salads
- Rolls & Calzones
- Hot Heroes
- Cold Heroes
- Wraps
- Burgers
- Pasta
- Dinners
- Children's Menu
- Desserts
- Catering
Meet Little Pop
Our Story
A Neighborhood Slice Joint
Little Pops is the corner pizzeria on Homestead Ave in Maybrook, run by Steve and Lou Smith. It's a straight-ahead New York pizzeria — big foldable slices, hot heroes, baked pasta and wings, out of a hot oven and onto your plate.
Grab a slice at lunch, call ahead for a pie on the way home, or let us cater the whole party. Stop in and say hi — Steve and Lou will take care of you.
A Peek Inside
From the Shop
Come On In
Hours & Location
Hours
- Mon–Sat
- 11 AM – 9 PM
- Sun
- 12 PM – 8 PM
87 Homestead Ave
Maybrook, NY 12543
Feeding the Whole Block
Catering for Any Occasion
Steve & Lou Smith will personally build a menu for your event and budget — trays of pasta, parm, salads, wings, heroes and more. Half trays feed 7–10, full trays feed 15–20.
Good to Know
Questions & Answers
- Do you deliver, and how far?
- Yes — we deliver within about a 6-mile radius of the shop. There's a $15 order minimum and a $3 delivery charge.
- How do I place an order?
- Call us at (845) 636-4156, order online through Slice, or order on DoorDash. Walk-ins are always welcome too.
- How long does a pickup order take?
- Most pickup orders are ready in about 20 to 30 minutes.
- Can I dine in?
- Yes — there's seating for about 20. It's a relaxed, order-at-the-counter spot, so grab a slice or a whole pie and eat in.
- Is Little Pops wheelchair accessible?
- Yes — our shop is wheelchair accessible. Come on in.
- What payment methods do you accept?
- All major methods — cash, credit and debit cards, and contactless tap-to-pay like Apple Pay and Google Pay. There's no card minimum.
- Do you run any specials?
- Yes! Large pizza is just $12 every Monday and Tuesday. On Fridays you get a free topping with any large pizza, and on Saturdays a free 2-liter with any large pizza. We also run weekday lunch specials from $7.99 (Mon–Fri, 11 am–3 pm) and combo deals on pizza and wings — just ask.
- Do you have gluten-free options?
- Yes — our cauliflower crust is gluten-free, and a small gluten-free menu is on the way.
- Do you have vegan or vegetarian options?
- Lots of vegetarian choices. Our dough is egg-free, so it's vegan-friendly — we don't carry vegan cheese, but a cheese-free pie loaded with veggies is always a great option.
- Do you cater parties and events?
- Absolutely. We cater events of all sizes — please give us about a week's notice. Call (845) 636-4156 and Steve or Lou will build a menu for your occasion.
Hungry Yet?
Order a Hot One Tonight
Order online for pickup or delivery, or give us a call — we're firing up pies right now.